Did Bloggers Have a Negative Impact on Fashion Week?

By Cate Sevilla

When you hear that runway models are thin, that the fashion industry doesn’t like to eat, and that Fashion Week is filled with pretentious, rude, over-dress snobs –you think that for the most part, it’s just a myth.

Surely, things can’t be that stereotypical. Surely the models aren’t that thin. Surely the fashion industry isn’t as icey as Anna Wintour herself.

However, the models were that thin. Food wasn’t exactly flowing, while the champagne most certainly was, and I wasn’t exactly bowled over by people’ friendliness.

But – I’m not complaining.

I find Fashion Week’s absolutely fascinating, and I have a love-hate relationship with the fashion industry. It’s a freak show. It’s awe-inspiring. It’s disgusting, it’s dark, but for some reason I really loved it.

I’m perfectly happy being in situations where everyone is an attention whore and wanting to have their photos taken by The Daily photographers or anyone else with an SLR ,as it means it’s easier for me to duck in and out of things, blend in, and do my work.

Unlike a lot of journalists and fashion bloggers there, I was at Fashion Week to work. Not to be seen. Not to drink champagne. Not to freak out over celebrities on Twitter.

If that’s why you were there, that’s fine. Your prerogative. However, what I don’t appreciate is that that Press Accreditations were given out as freely as those little bottles of Chambord.

As a result, the exhibitors and designers were a bit wary when people came up to them, their press creds slung over their neck, digicam in hand, touting that they’re from “The ____ Blog” and would like to take their photo.

I mentioned before that I was curious to see how bloggers being allowed into LFW as press would affect anything, if at all, and to be honest, the only impact I saw or felt - aside from the fact that I recognized people, was a negative one.

As much as I am all for bloggers being embraced by designers and the high street – let’s have some quality control.

Not every fashion  blogger out there is Susie Bubble, or even the next Susie Bubble, and that’s a good thing. The reason people like Susie are allowed into certain shows or invited to this that and the other by the likes of Topshop and other brands is because she works her well-dressed ass off.

But, to the fault of many a PR agency, people don’t understand that not all Bloggers are of the same calibre, and therefore, just because someone says they’re a fashion blogger, it doesn’t mean that they write and take the same standard of photos as Mademoiselle Robot or have the same influence as Susie.

I cannot be the only person who noted that they apparently let anyone and everyone in as "press".

I actually like things being exclusive, even if it means that I cannot get in. Even if I am on the outside. 

It means that I need to try harder, or do something different, or wait a year. Maybe it means that  I need to grow a little more. That way, when/if I do get in, I know it means something.

When PR agencies and brands just throw around the term “fashion blogger” or “press” without any real clear definition of what that means, or to what standards those accredited are being held to, it brings down the value of the credentials. The quality of the coverage goes down. Those press passes and golden ticket invites to Jaeger mean less.

I am not one to buy into high-fashion bullshit or think that I am unworthy to breathe the same air as Alexa Chung.

However, I do respect the fashion industry as a powerful and influential British Institution, and so I respect what London Fashion Week is about. I respect the designers both big and small. I respect how damn lucky we all were to be able to meet designers at the On|Off Exhibition, and that it was a privilege to see Peter Jensen’s collection up close and personal.

While journalists already barely had a leg to stand on when it came to appreciating the things they’re given or allowed to attend – the combination of both bloggers and journalists being lazy and indulging in every free thing they can get their WAH-nailed fingers on drags those journalists and bloggers who do work their asses off and care and respect what they’re doing through the mud.

I am honoured and excited that blogging has become mainstream and that they are finally “worthy” enough of press credentials to certain events and conferences.

However, we need some quality control. A bit of vetting.

Remember when Twitter went mainstream? The amount of Spam increased. You had fake accounts left and right, people who didn’t believe in having meaningful conversations or sharing interesting things they’ve found online – instead they just constantly Tweeted links to things they’ve done. Or asked you to look at their "hot pix".

Blogging has become the same. Everyone thinks they can do it –and with the help of Wordpress they can – but that doesn’t mean that they can do it well. Or professionally.

 Or to a standard that should deem them as “press”.

Image via Foxtongue's Flickr

POSTED IN: STYLE
Wed, 23 Sep 2009 12:00 (GMT+00)
15 Responses
1.

Thanks for this, you're making a really good point which i've been thinking about a lot recently. Am currently formulating a blog post on bloggers and the fashion industry as a matter of fact!

Hannah
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 12:13 GMT
2.

I suspect that over time it will settle down and bloggers will find their place in the pantheon of Fashion Press.

With a backlog of Fashion Week coverage behind them it will be easier for LFW to assess bloggers next season and decide wether to award them access or not. Some might make it, others won't.

I really appreciated the opportunity this year to get my press credentials, and I went to work, not star spot or blag freebies. I'm hoping I can turn this into an opportunity to continue to attend in future. I suspect that had it not been for the handing out of press passes willy nilly I wouldn't have been there at all and would have missed a great opportunity.

Retro Chick
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 12:16 GMT
3.

Retro Chick -

Word. If I had been denied accreditation, fine. Fair enough. Those who got in who probably wouldn't have done otherwise, but worked their asses off and covered as much as they could were simply making the most of a golden opportunity. It's when you look a gift horse in the mouth, and then just sit around drinking champagne and taking half-assed photos that I start to wonder.

Thanks for the comment! x

Cate
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 12:22 GMT
4.

I agree with retro chick: I was very grateful for an opportunity I dont think I would have otherwise been given. I worked hard and wrote up every single show and presentation I attended as soon as I could (although my pictures definitely aren't up to Mme Robot's high standards!)

Hopefully this will all mean something next year and anyone who didn't make the effort won't be invited again!!

PS -I must've been doing something wrong because i didn't get a single freebie!

tor (fabfrocks)
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 12:25 GMT
5.

Love this post!

Isabelle
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 12:49 GMT
6.

I agree most wholeheartedly. I was here to work but I also run a blog and I wondered how PRs chose who got to go and who didn't. Mademoiselle Robot's posts are a case in point of how to do it. Some bloggers got access as good I did as a journalist and haven't posted anything or have done it in a half-arsed way. I work really hard on my blog and am overwhelmed when I get given any attention for it and am certainly not in it for the freebies.

Retro Chick is right to say that quality will show itself in the end and I think maintaining some journalistic standards is a fair return for getting tickets to shows.

S Disconap
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 13:25 GMT
7.

I agree, speaking about New York Fashion Week here. It's almost embarassing to say you're "online" media because you know the PRs are internally rolling their eyes. My question is how do you maintain this quality control? What are the standards? That would be really difficult and I feel talented bloggers are bound to be left out if they don't have the readership or fancy design of other blogs. It would be a real interesting discussion to see what the criteria were.

Andrea
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 13:41 GMT
8.

-Andrea, I think there are a few ways to maintain the quality control, one way would be to hold all entrants accountable for their coverage, have seen a few events that require bloggers to agree to a "post quota", would this hurt so much to journalist too, require them to write x articles.

Also, how do you measure who is a talented blogger? If you're a fantastic journalist, but never had a mainstream publication print one of your articles, would they get in? So are we talking about letting both bloggers and journalists in based on potential, not actual talent?

Iain
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 14:31 GMT
9.

I am glad so many people take this matter at heart...

Since the last Fashion Week in February, there has been a crazy increase in the number of bloggers in attendance, yet the coverage hasn't been better.
I have seen a few "familiar" faces (read "recognised from online) doing a lot of hanging around, all dressed up, but not a post in sight on their blogs. Somerset House isn't Disneyland (even if it has a lot in common with it), most people go there to work everyday. It is a trade event, like any other one. People from a specific industry go there to meet, greet and discover things specific to their industry.

Would you go to the annual convention of Chartered Surveyors and send endless Tweets about sightings of Mr Smith, the president of the association? Or go there just to stand in the middle hoping to be noticed? NO.
You would go there and work your ass off for 5 days, taking it for what it is: a golden opportunity to generate content if you are press, or a great way to network and find new talents if you are a buyer. That's IT.
Also, you would make sure you bring a decent camera. I am sorry, but camera phones photographs are NOT suitable material to illustrate an article.

I hope that next time the Circus comes to town, there will be less hanger arounders, less tweetbragging, less blabber about celebrities, and MORE WORK DONE. If you have the lanyard around your neck, you gotta make momma proud.

I have to say also: how many street style bloggers will we have to put up with next time? It is becoming totally ridiculous, and they all end up posting the same photographs with varying quality.

Mademoiselle Robot
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 14:56 GMT
10.

I really love and appreciate this post, Cate. I know Comic Con isn't LFW, but I had a very similar experience when I was in San Diego for that event... It was frustrating to be someone running my ass off, chasing stories and generating content only to be lumped into the same category as the blogger-people who the Con staff had granted press credentials to who weren't doing a damn thing other than enjoying a free weekend in San Diego.

I was there to cover the event, not to play and it was annoying to me when I was exhausted and trying to work to have those types of bloggers cluttering up the press room.

Kate
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 16:48 GMT
11.

Great article, Cate. There's lots of issues to struggle with as we try to represent for online media but you're totally right that there are many bloggers out there who give us a very bad name. We certainly don't get the same respect. At the MTV VMA's red carpet, it was so blatant was they lined up all the big-name sources on one side and all the not-as-big-names on the other side. Many of the big celebs didn't even bother coming over to our side, or by the time they got to us, their PR was dragging them away.

Andrea & Iain, I think a quality blog speaks for itself. In the celeb blog world, it's very easy to see who is putting out good content that's not just stealing photos, calling people names, and pasting press releases. I think the same can be said for any other blog niche.

maria
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 18:48 GMT
12.

Hi there,
You are great writer, something that I lack confidence in. I really appreciate what you have written. I work in the fashion industry as a freelancer and take part in LFW as I usually work for a big designer that shows, for the last 5 seasons just not this one.
Anyway I digress! I see the Susie's running about fluttering their eyelashes at some and dismissing others. And the rubbish blogs that are the result of their waffling. I just laugh at these people and enjoy the events, I work very hard and don't appreciate flippant comments from people who don't really know what they're talking about. Many of them wouldn't be able to cope with what we do over a number of weeks of long hours on the lead up to LFW. But I love it and really missed not taking part this season. And having to read through chaff to find the wheat was a little annoying.
So again well done and thanks for this great bit of writing.

Linda
Wed, 23-Sep-2009 19:49 GMT
13.

Another great piece, Cate. I'm kinda glad I scived off fashion week this year, but it certainly seems that all the PR agencies just kinda went hoopla with the news that the Arcadia blogger event was A Good Thing and that we're not just a bunch of weirdos/freeloaders. I agree with Retro Chick (hey again cake pal!) that hopefully the resultant coverage will help separate the good from the bad for next season.

rachael gibson
Fri, 25-Sep-2009 23:37 GMT
14.

I don't have a fashion blog, but I do get tired of going to 'fashion blogs' and seeing the same things time after time, and usually exactly the same photos that are taken by someone who is working their arse off to get the photos and then get recognition for said photos. Often, photographers aren't given credits for images used either. The other thing that really drives me nuts is the quality of the writing. If you are going to be given free entry into an event like LFW, at least write an entry that is readable in terms of syntax, punctuation, and other grammar things. Surely that isn't too much to ask for.

Kelly
Sun, 27-Sep-2009 06:21 GMT
15.

I agree with you that it's annoying, but the same thing happened before bloggers were allowed in- there will always be press at the shows that aren't bothering.

PR agencies don't have the time to check people's blogs, they work just as hard as everyone else in the weeks leading up to fashion week, and until there are enough bloggers who have networked and made a name for themselves (just as magazines have to) it's going to be tough to weed out the seat wasters.

Meg
Wed, 27-Jan-2010 14:37 GMT

Add Comment

Note: Your email address will be verified but will never be published on the site.

If you are a registered user, please Sign In.




The opinions expressed by the author and commenters are their own and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of BitchBuzz or any employer or organisation. The aforementioned are not responsible for the accuracy of content published.